(Click PAGE MENU To See Topics Covered On This Page. Scroll down the page to see all Menu Topic Information. Click the X to close the page menu) PAGE MENU
Add Protection Now! Top 9 Battery Backup Sump Pumps
Sooner or later, whether it is from a power outage or a malfunctioning electric primary sump pump float switch, your pump will likely fail during a heavy rainstorm leaving your basement vulnerable to flooding. Do not wait until disaster strikes! Investing in a reliable battery backup sump pump ensures you are always prepared, giving you peace of mind even when the power goes out.
With a wide variety of battery backup sump pumps available, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one for your water pumping needs. That is why we have compiled this guide to highlight the top 9 battery backup sump pumps on the market today.
Do not let power outages leave your basement vulnerable! Explore our guide for the top 9 battery backup sump pumps and find the perfect fit for your needs.
Click the Table Of Contents button to Hide it. Click it again to see it.
Battery Back Up Sump Pump Top 9 Table of Contents
Select a specific topic for Battery Back Up Sump Pumps Top 9 if you wish to read about the topic immediately. Otherwise scroll down the page to see all topics.
Top 9 Battery Backup Pumps Identity By Remarkable Features
Best Value: Basement Watchdog BWSP (good performance for the price). Easy to install, good support and Wi-Fi- connectivity accessory available..
Best Built For Heavy Duty Pumping: Zoeller 508-005. Zoeller builds their own motors for performance and durability. For best performance. an 18 inch diameter and at least a 24 inch deep pit is required.
Most Durable For Smaller Pumping Demands:: Zoeller 507-0005 is built with the same quality as Zoeller 508-005 but with less pumping capacity.
Most Affordable: Superior Pump 92910 and Watchdog BWE (budget-friendly but with some limitations)..
Most Budget Friendly Heavy Duty Pump: Basement Watchdog Big Dog BWD12-120 pumps more than the average battery backup sump pump and has the popular features of Wi-Fi connectivity option, dual float switch, two battery hook up in parallel.
Simple! No Wi-Fi But Average Pump Performance: Wayne ESP25n upgrade from the popular ESP25; however with slightly less pumping performance. Budget friendly.
Best Low Capacity Pumping Wayne ESP25n upgrade from the popular ESP25; however with slightly less pumping performance. Budget friendly.
Best for Alexa and Google Assistant Compatibility: Liberty Pumps 442 with the NightEye technology accessory.
Solid 1/3 HP Pumping Performance Equivalence: Glentronics Pro Series PHCC1850 with 1850 GPH at a 10 foot vertical height.
Battery Backup Sump Pump Top 9 Comparisons By Distinct Features
In this section, we are diving into a detailed comparison of the Top 9 battery backup sump pumps, focusing on their performance, key features, and overall value. Whether you need an affordable, efficient option or a high-end, heavy-duty system, we will help you find the right solution. By comparing these Best Top 9 models side by side, you w;il gain a clearer understanding of what sets each one apart, making it easier to choose the pump that best fits your water pumping needs.
PAGE MENU
Zoeller 507-0005 vs 508-0005 vs 508-0014
Zoeller is widely respected for its reliable, American-made sump pumps. This guide compares three battery backup models:
- Zoeller 507-0005 (Aquanot Key) -Entry-level DC backup
- Zoeller 508-0005 (Aquanot Spin) - Mid-tier with more capacity and smart diagnostics
- Zoeller 508-0014 (Aquanot Fit) - Premium version with built-in Wi-Fi and remote monitoring
Similarities: Key Features Across These Zoeller Models
Quality Craftsmanship
- All three models are hand-built and 100% tested in Zoellers U.S. facility.
- Zoeller emphasizes individual craftsmanship over mass production.
Airlock Protection
- A Smart Controller is included in each system, which automatically initiates an airlock purge routine (on/off/on/off/on) to release trapped air that could prevent the pump from operating.
System Self-Checks
-Each model runs automatic system checks to verify that the controller, battery, and pump are functioning correctly, reducing the risk of unnoticed failure and performing the .airlock purge routine as necessary.
Vortex Impeller Design
-The pumps use a vortex-style impeller, which can handle small solids present in sump pits. This reduces clogging and maintenance while improving pump lifespan.
Battery Compatibility And Charging
- All three models use Zoellers 10-1450 battery (Group 27 AGM, 12V, 72Ah), designed specifically for these backup systems.
-Both AGM and flooded deep cycle batteries are supported.
-Battery charger is 10 amps, allowing a full recharge of a Group 27 battery in approximately 10-14 hours.
-You can connect two batteries in parallel on any of these systems to extend runtime-commonly doubling backup duration.
Warranty
-The 3 models include a 3-year warranty, a strong industry offering for backup systems.
Differences: What Sets Each Zoeller Model Apart
Pumping Power And Capacity
-If you are looking for more power, the Zoeller 508-0005, is the clear winner. It offers 34 GPM and 2,040 GPH at a 10-foot vertical height, making it a powerhouse for your sump pumping needs. In comparison, the 507-0005 pumps at a much lower rate of 15 GPM and 900 GPH at the same height..
-To put it in perspective: The Zoeller 508-0005, performance is on par with Zoellers 1/3 HP primary sump pumps like the M53, M57, and M63, , all delivering 2,040 GPH. On the other hand, the 507-0005 matches the pumping capacity of a 1/4 HP primary sump pump, so it is more suitable for lighter-duty tasks.
-If you opt for the 508-0005, keep in mind it requires a larger sump pit. Zoeller recommends a pit that is at least 18 inches in diameter and 24 inches deep to get the best performance..
Battery Life and Charging: How Long Will They Run?
-Both pumps can handle battery group size 27, but the 507-0005 also supports group size 29, while the 508-0005 can handle an even bigger group size 31 battery. This gives you a bit more flexibility in choosing your battery. In terms of runtime, you can expect 7 hours continuous operation with the 507-0005 when using Zoeller battery 10-1450. The 508-0005 gives you about 6 hours of continuous use. Both models are designed to run for 55 hours at a 10% duty cycle, so they will handle long-term backup needs with ease.
Notable Features: Extra Perks with the 508-0005
Self-Testing Customization: One cool feature exclusive to the 508-0005 is the ability to customize the self-testing schedule. The 507-0005 has a fixed self-test schedule, which is preset at the factory.
High Water Sensor: The 508-0005 also has the option to add a High Water Sensor, which acts as a backup float switch if the primary float switch fails. This is another added layer of security that the 507-0005 does not offer.
Wi-Fi Connectivity: This is a game-changer for the 508-0014. It comes with built-in Wi-Fi and is Z Control enabled, allowing you to monitor and control your pump remotely via Zoeller Z Control Cloud service. You can monitor, test, and silence the pump system from anywhere, and even receive alerts via email, text, or push notifications. Plus, the best part? There are no monthly fees for the cloud service. Unfortunately, the 507-0005 does not have this feature.
Price: Which One Fits Your Budget?
If you are on a budget, the Zoeller 507-0005 is the more affordable option at $356.00. However, the 508-0005 comes in at a higher price, of $465.00 due to its added power and advanced features. If you want the Wi-Fi connectivity and the full range of smart features, then the Zoeller 508-0014 might be the one for you, but it will cost you $726.00.
Installation: A Quick Setup or More Work?
Both models are relatively easy to install with clear instructions, making them a good option for DIYers. However, if you go with the 508-0014 (with the Wi-Fi feature), it will take a bit longer to set up due to the additional configuration needed for the smart features.
Final Thoughts: Is Zoeller 507-0005 Or Zoeller 508-0005 Best For You?
So, which pump is right for you? Here is a quick rundown:
Go for the Zoeller 507-0005 if you are looking for a solid, budget-friendly backup pump for lighter-duty needs..
Choose the Zoeller 508-0005 if you need more power, have a larger sump pit, and want additional features like the customizable self-testing and the High Water Sensor option that acts as a backup to the float switch.
If remote monitoring and Wi-Fi connectivity essential for you, the Zoeller 508-0014 is the way to go, but keep in mind the higher price tag.
If your basement is finished or flood-prone, the added features and higher pumping capacity of the 508-0005 or 508-0014 make them well worth the investment.
Basement Watchdog BWE vs. BWSP: A Side-by-Side Comparison
When it comes to keeping your basement dry, the Basement Watchdog BWE and BWSP are two reliable options to consider. While both systems offer excellent protection, there are a few key similarities and differences that can help you decide which is the best fit for your water pumping needs.
Similarities: Key Features For Basement Watchdog BWE and BWSP
Both the BWE and BWSP systems share a lot of impressive features that make them stand out.
:
-Compact Design: The compact design of both models allows for easy installation in smaller or narrow sump pits, making them ideal for spaces where every inch counts.
-Dual Float Switches for Added Protection: Each system comes with dual float switches, ensuring that if one fails, the other will still kick in to activate the pump. This redundancy minimizes the risk of unexpected basement flooding.
-24/7 Monitoring: Both pumps feature continuous monitoring of the pump, power, and battery. This ensures your system is always ready to work, even during an emergency.
-Automatic Activation: Whether there is a power failure or your main pump stops working, both systems automatically switch to battery power and start pumping to prevent water damage,.
-User-Friendly Controllers: Both models feature easy-to-use controllers that monitor everything from pump and power conditions to battery status. You will get both visual and audible alerts for any irregularities, so you always know the status of your system.
-User-Friendly Control Panels: The easy-to-read control panels light up to alert you when attention is needed. Plus, they clearly explain what action you should take for quick and simple maintenance.
-Audible and Visual Alarms: Both systems come with audible and visual alarms that will alert you to any potential issues, like low battery power, low battery fluid levels, pump activation (indicating a main pump failure), or an interrupted AC power supply.
-Maintenance-Free AGM Batteries: Forget about regularly adding water or worrying about maintenance-both systems are compatible with maintenance-free AGM batteries. This means less hassle for you and reliable performance when you need it most.
-Battery Compatibility: Both models are designed to work with Basement Watchdog AGM and wet-cell batteries, giving you flexibility in choosing the right power source for your needs.
-Two-Year Limited Warranty: Each system comes with a 2-year limited warranty, offering peace of mind with your purchase.
-Automatic Charging: Keeping your battery charged is effortless with the automatic charging system, ensuring the battery is always ready when you need it most.
-Fairly easy to install, with clear instructions provided. Customer support is available and helpful. Can be installed on the bottom of the pit or in line with the PVC discharge used by the primary sump pump.
Key Differences: Basement Watchdog BWE vs. BWSP
Here is a breakdown of the differences between the Basement Watchdog BWE and Basement Watchdog BWSP models to help you make an informed decision.
Pumping Power And Capacity
-BWSP: The BWSP is the more powerful option, capable of pumping 30 GPM (Gallons Per Minute) and 1,850 GPH (Gallons Per Hour) at a 10-foot vertical height. This performance is comparable to a 1/3 HP primary sump pump, making it ideal for larger or more demanding sump pump needs.
-BWE: On the other hand, the BWE has a lower pumping capacity, delivering 16 GPM and 1,000 GPH at a 10-foot vertical height. This performance is comparable to a 1/4 HP primary sump pump, suitable for smaller spaces or less intense water flow.
Battery Life and Charging
Battery Charging:
-The BWSP comes with an automatic 1.6 Amp charger designed to maintain the battery at full charge even when the pump is not in use, ensuring that it is always ready to go when you need it most.
-In contrast, the BWE has a smaller 0.4 Amp charger, so while it still charges the battery, it does so at a slower rate.
Battery Compatibility:
-The BWE supports Group 24 or Group 27 deep cycle batteries, offering flexibility in your choice of power source..
-The BWSP , however, is designed specifically for a Group 27 battery, with the Basement Watchdog BW-27AGM maintenance-free AGM battery being the recommended choice. This 12-volt battery has a 75 amp-hour rating, providing reliable power for extended use.
Battery Status & Monitoring
-BWE: features a simple indicator that tells you whether the battery charge is good or bad-keeping things straightforward.
-BWSP: The BWSP takes it a step further, offering a battery status indicator that shows the battery charge level. This makes it easier to monitor the health of your system and avoid surprises.
Additional Features
-System Check: The BWSP has an automatic system check that runs regular diagnostics, ensuring everything is functioning properly and minimizing the risk of pump failure.
-Dual Battery Support: A standout feature of the BWSP is the ability to connect two batteries in the event of a power outage. The BWE does not support this feature.
-Wi-Fi Connectivity: The BWSP is compatible with the BW-Wi-Fi2 connectivity accessory, allowing you to monitor your sump pump remotely via smartphone or tablet. This is a great addition for peace of mind.
Price Difference
-BWE: For those on a budget, the BWE is the more affordable option, priced around $151 (as of publication).
-BWSP: The BWSP comes in at a higher price point, approximately $268. While it is more expensive, the additional power, features, and dual battery support may justify the extra cost for those with larger or more demanding sump pump needs.
Final Thoughts: Is Watchdog BWE Or BWSP Best For You?
So, which pump is right for you? Here is a quick summary:
If you are looking for a budget-friendly, reliable option for a smaller or less demanding space, the BWE is a solid choice.
However, if you need more power, longer run time, and added features like battery status monitoring and Wi-Fi connectivity, the BWSP is a better investment.
Wayne ESP25n vs. Superior 92900 and 92910 Comparison
If you are on the hunt for a reliable yet simple battery backup sump pump, comparing the Wayne ESP25n with the Superior 92900 and 92910 makes perfect sense. These two pumps have more in common with each other than they do with the other seven models on our list. While both offer basic functionality, they come with limitations that more modern models have addressed.
Similarities: What Wayne ESP25 and Superior 92900 and 92910 Have in Common
-Single Float Switch: Both pumps use a single float switch with no additional high water float alarm. If the float fails, neither pump will operate. They rely on a vertical reed switch for operation, which is a basic yet reliable mechanism..
-Installation Flexibility: Both pumps can be installed either above the electric primary pump in line with the discharge pipe or at the bottom of the sump pit, giving you some flexibility based on your setup.
-Battery Compatibility: These pumps use standard battery group sizes 24 or 27, which are widely available.
-Lack of Wi-Fi Connectivity: If you are looking for smart features like remote monitoring, neither of these models offers Wi-Fi connectivity.
Key Differences: Wayne ESP25n vs. Superior 92900 and 92910
Power and Capacity
- The Wayne ESP25n outshines the Superior 92900 and 92910 in terms of power and performance. The Wayne ESP25n can pump 25 GPM and 1500 GPH at a 10-foot vertical height, while the Superior models only manage 18 GPM and 1080 GPH at the same height. This difference in performance is significant, especially if you are dealing with heavier water flow or a deeper sump pit. In terms of power, the ESP25n is closer to 1/3 HP, while the Superior models sit around 1/4 HP.
Battery Life And Charging
- One downside of the Wayne ESP25n is its weak battery charger. At less than 1 Amp it takes about 24 hours to fully recharge a depleted battery. In comparison the Superior charger is much stronger at 2 Amps, meaning it recharges the battery faster. Both pumps are easy to install-no need for a pro, and neither requires Wi-Fi setup, which some DIYers will appreciate.
Warranty And Durability
- The Wayne ESP25n comes with a 2-year warranty offering more peace of mind than the Superior 92900 and 92910, which only have 1-year warranties.
Notable Features
- Tether float switch: The standout feature of the Superior 92900 is its tether float switch, a nice addition for those who prefer more water to be removed from the pit each pump cycle.
-Price: When it comes to cost, the Superior 92900 is the most budget-friendly, priced at $169, followed by the Superior 92910 at $220. The Wayne ESP25n is the most expensive of the bunch, coming in at $413. Given its limited features, we believe the ESP25n is a bit overpriced for what it offers.
Final Thoughts: Is Wayne ESP25n Or Superior 92910 Right For You?
So, which one is best for you? If you are looking for a more powerful pump and longer-lasting warranty, the Wayne ESP25n could be worth the investment. But if you are after a more budget-friendly option, the Superior 92900 and 92910 provide solid performance without breaking the bank. Just keep in mind that these models lack some of the advanced features of newer pumps.
Liberty Pumps 442-10A vs. Liberty Pumps 25A vs Zoeller 508-0014
In this comparison, we will look at three standout models from Liberty Pumps and Zoeller
- Liberty Pumps 442-10A (StormCell with Night Eye): One battery hookup.
- Liberty Pumps 442-25A (StormCell with Night Eye): Two battery hookup for double the runtime.
- Zoeller 508-0014 (Aquanot Fit with Wi-Fi): Two battery hookup for double the runtime.
While all three of these pumps are built to last and offer key features, they differ in pumping performance, battery capacity, and additional features. Let's look at the details.
Similarities: What The Liberty Pumps 442 And Zoeller 508-0014 Have In Common
Before we look at the differences, let's highlight some of the core features that these pumps share.
:
Quality Craftsmanship
-Made in the USA: Both Liberty Pumps and Zoeller are well-known for their reliable, American-made products. Each of these models is hand-built and rigorously tested to ensure top-notch performance.
-Durable Design: These pumps prioritize quality over mass production, ensuring each unit is crafted with attention to detail and built to last.
Vortex Impeller Design
-Better for Small Solids: All three pumps use a vortex-style impeller, which helps handle small solids (like dirt and debris) in sump pits. This reduces clogging and maintenance, extending the pump lifespan.
Battery Compatibility And Charging
-Battery Group Sizes: These pumps support Battery Group Sizes 27 or 31, with Zoeller models (508-0005 and 508-0014) also running with Group Size 29.
-Deep Cycle Batteries: Both AGM and flooded deep cycle batteries are supported across all these models.
-Dual Battery Setup: Zoeller 508-0005, 508-0014, and Liberty 442-25A can connect two batteries in parallel to extend runtime. The Liberty 442-10A, however, supports only one battery.
Warranty
-Solid Coverage: Both Zoeller and Liberty Pumps offer a 3-year warranty on their backup systems, providing peace of mind for buyers.
Key Differences: Liberty Pumps 442 vs Zoeller 508-0014
Now, let's take a closer look at what makes these models unique.
Pumping Power And Capacity
If you need more power for larger spaces or heavier rainfalls, Zoeller pumps are the clear winners.
-Zoeller 508-0005 and 508-0014: These models deliver an impressive 34 GPM and 2,040 GPH at a 10-foot vertical height, making them great for larger basements or areas with higher water volume. Their performance is comparable to Zoeller 1/3 HP primary sump pumps, such as the M53, M57, and M63.
-Liberty Pumps 442-10A and 442-25A: These models deliver 30 GPM and 1,800 GPH at a 10-foot vertical height, making them ideal for smaller to medium-sized spaces but not quite as powerful as the Zoeller models.
Quick Tip: If you have a larger sump pit, Zoeller recommends a pit that is at least 18 inches in diameter and 24 inches deep to get optimal performance from their pumps.
Battery Charging and Compatibility
-Zoeller Models: Both Zoeller 508-0005 and 508-0014 support a 20 Amp battery charger.
-Liberty 442-25A : uses a 25 Amp charger allowing for faster battery recharging.
-Dual Battery Support: The Zoeller 508-0005, 508-0014, and Liberty 442-25A all support dual battery setups, giving you double the runtime during power outages. The Liberty 442-10A however, is limited to just one battery..
System Self-Checks
-Zoeller 508-0014: Offers automatic system checks, ensuring the controller, battery, and pump are all functioning properly. This reduces the risk of an unnoticed failure.
-Liberty Pumps: Neither the 442-10A nor the 442-25A offer this automatic self-testing feature, so it is recommended you periodically check the system manually.
Battery Life and Runtime
Both brands are designed to keep your sump pit dry when your primary pump fails, but here is how they differ in runtime.
-Zoeller 508-0005: Provides about 6 hours of continuous use or 55 hours at a 10% duty cycle.
-Liberty Pumps 442-25A: According to Liberty, the 442-25A can run up to 11 continuous days with a StormCell Group 31 battery and 16 days intermittently. This makes it a great option if you need long-term backup..
Notable Features Yet Unique By Brand Model
Here is what makes these models even more attractive and unique..
-Customizable Self-Testing: Only Zoeller 508-0014 allows you to customize the self-testing schedule, ensuring your system is always ready for action. This feature is not available on the Liberty Pumps models.
-High Water Sensor: The Zoeller 508-0005 includes a High Water Sensor, which serves as a backup float switch in case the primary float fails. The Liberty 442-25A features a redundant high-water float switch, offering extra peace of mind.
-Wi-Fi Connectivity Both Liberty and Zoeller models have smart features, but Zoeller takes it a step further with built-in Wi-Fi and Z Control. This lets you monitor and control your pump remotely via a smartphone app, without any monthly fees. Liberty Pumps 442-25A offers NightEye wireless alarm system, which is also cloud-based and does not require a subscription. Plus, it is Alexa-compatible, a feature that Zoeller lacks.
Price: Which One Fits Your Budget?
While price is a major consideration, you are also paying for the features and reliability these models offer.
-Zoeller 508-0005: At around $465: this is the most affordable option and a great choice for those who need powerful pumping at a reasonable price.
-Zoeller 508-0014: For those who want Wi-Fi connectivity and more advanced features, the 508-0014 is priced at $726:
-Liberty Pumps 442-10A: This model costs about $1,182, offering a single-battery setup with advanced features like NightEye.
-Liberty Pumps 442-10A: For those who want Wi-Fi connectivity and more advanced features, the 508-0014 is priced at $726:
-Liberty Pumps 442-25A: If you need double the runtime and extra features, the 442-25A will cost you around $1,557.
Installation: Easy Setup
While price is a major consideration, you are also paying for the features and reliability these models offer.
-Both Zoeller and Liberty Pumps are easy to install, with clear manuals and helpful customer support. The Wi-Fi setup may take a little longer, but it is user-friendly and can be done by most DIYers.
Final Thoughts: Is Liberty Pumps 442 Or Zoeller 508-0014 Right For You?
Here is a quick breakdown to help you make your decision:
-Go for the Zoeller 508-0014 if you need a high-powered pump for larger areas and prefer the added benefit of Wi-Fi connectivity for remote monitoring.
-Choose the Liberty Pumps 442-25A if you want Alexa compatibility and extended runtime with two batteries, but be prepared for the higher price tag.
-If you are on a budget, the Zoeller 508-0005 offers great performance at a more affordable price.
Ultimately, both brands deliver high-quality, reliable performance. If you have a finished basement or live in an area prone to flooding, either of these pumps will provide the peace of mind you need to protect your home.
Basement Watchdog BWD12-120 vs. Glentronics ProSeries PHCC1850 Comparison
In this comparison, we will look at these models from Basement Watchdog and Glantronics.
The Basement Watchdog BWD12-120 and Glentronics ProSeries PHCC1850 both offer solid protection, but they come with unique features. Here is a breakdown of their similarities and differences to help you make the best choice.
Similarities Between The BWD12-120 And PHCC1850
Both models deliver excellent flood protection and reliability. Here is what they share.
:
-Automatic Battery Backup: if you need a high-powered pump for larger areas and prefer the added benefit of Wi-Fi connectivity for remote monitoring.
-Dual Float Switch: Both come with a dual float switch, which adds redundancy. If one switch fails, the other will kick in to ensure continuous pumping.
-Dual Battery Support: Want to extend your system run time? Both models allow you to hook up two batteries in parallel, effectively doubling the pump run time during a power outage.
-Weekly Self-Testing: Both pumps perform a weekly self-test, though the schedule is pre-set and cannot be altered. This ensures your system stays in top shape.
-Wi-Fi Connectivity: Both models come with USB data ports and remote terminals for easy connection to a Wi-Fi module. This lets you receive notifications through home automation systems or mobile devices.
-Wi-Fi Modules: The PS-WiFi2 and BW-WiFi2 modules are compatible with both systems, allowing you to connect your sump pump to your home Wi-Fi and receive updates via the Basement Watchdog CONNECT mobile app.
-24/7 Monitoring: Continuous monitoring of your pump, power, and battery means your system is always ready to go, even in an emergency.
-Alarms and Alerts: Both systems feature audible and visual alarms to alert you of any issues like low battery power, low battery fluid levels, pump activation (if the main pump fails), or a disrupted AC power supply.
-User-Friendly Controllers: Easy-to-use controllers on both models monitor everything from pump and power conditions to battery status. You will get visual and audible alerts if anything goes wrong, keeping you informed.
-Battery Compatibility: Both pumps use a Group Size 27 battery, and you can opt for either a maintenance-free AGM battery or a wet-cell battery. AGM batteries are spill-proof, longer-lasting, and more convenient.
Differences Between the BWD12-120 And PHCC1850
While both models offer excellent features, there are some key differences.
Pumping Capacity
- The BWD12-120 offers a higher pumping capacity with 36 GPM (Gallons Per Minute) and 2,200 GPH (Gallons Per Hour) at a 10-foot vertical height.
- The PHCC1850 has a slightly lower capacity, pumping 30 GPM (Gallons Per Minute) and 1,850 GPH (Gallons Per Hour) at a 10-foot vertical height.
Battery Charging Speed
- The BWD12-120 comes with a 20 Amp battery charger, recharging your battery much faster.
- The PHCC1850 uses a smaller 1.6 Amp charger, which takes longer to recharge the battery.
Run Time
-When paired with the Basement Watchdog 7.5 Hour Standby Deep Cycle Battery the BWD12-120 is designed to run continuously for about 7.5 hours or intermittently for days.
- The PHCC1850 when paired with the B-1000 battery can run continuously for about 5 to 7 hours or for 50-70 hours, based on a 10% duty cycle.
Warranty Period
-The BWD12-120 offers a 2-year warranty.
-The PHCC1850 comes with a 3-year warranty, giving you a bit more peace of mind.
Price
-BWD12-120 is priced at $497.(at the time of publication), making it a bit of a higher-end option.
-The PHCC1850 is more budget-friendly, with a price tag of $346 (at the time of publication).
Final Thoughts: Are Basement Watchdog BWD12-120 and Glentronics ProSeries PHCC1850 A Good Choice For You?
Both the Basement Watchdog BWD12-120 and Glentronics ProSeries PHCC1850 offer outstanding protection for your basement, keeping it dry during power outages or pump failures.
- If you need higher pumping capacity and faster battery recharge times, the BWD12-120 may be the right choice for you, though it comes at a higher price point.
- On the other hand, the PHCC1850 offers solid performance at a lower price and comes with a longer warranty, ideal for those looking for a more budget-friendly option.
Comparison Conclusion: Which Battery Backup Sump Pump Is Right For You?
Choosing the right battery backup sump pump depends on your needs, space, and budget. Here is a quick summary guide to help you decide:
-Zoeller 507-0005: If you are after a reliable, budget-friendly pump for lighter-duty tasks, this is a solid choice.
-Zoeller 508-0005: Need more pumping power for a larger sump pit? The 508-0005 comes with customizable self-testing and a High Water Sensor, perfect for those who want a bit more peace of mind..
-Zoeller 508-0014: If Wi-Fi connectivity and remote monitoring for a larger sump pit? The 508-0005 comes with customizable self-testing and a High Water Sensor, are non-negotiable for you, the 508-0014 offers these high-tech features, though it comes at a premium price.
-Wayne ESP25n: Looking for a basic battery backup system with no Wi-Fi connectivity? The ESP25n is a great investment for bigger needs.
-If you are on a budget, check out the Superior 92900 and 92910 for solid performance at a lower price.
-Basement Watchdog BWE: If you need a budget-friendly, reliable pump for a smaller space the BWE is a great option.
-Basement Watchdog BWSP: If you want more power, longer runtime, and features like Wi-Fi and battery status monitoring, consider stepping up to the BWSP,
-Basement Watchdog BWD12-120: For those needing a high-capacity pump with fast battery recharge, this model offers excellent protection, but keep in mind it comes at a higher price.
-Glentronics ProSeries PHCC1850: For those on a tighter budget, the PHCC1850 offers great performance and a longer warranty, making it a solid choice for value seekers.
-Liberty Pumps 442-25A: This one is for those who want Alexa compatibility and the ability to double runtime with two batteries, but be ready to pay a bit more.
Final Thoughts
Whether you are after the top-of-the-line features or just need something to keep your basement dry during a power outage, both Zoeller and Liberty Pumps offer reliable, high-quality options. Even Basement Watchdog Big Dog is for a finished basement or a home in a flood-prone area. These brands will keep you safe and dry, so it ultimately comes down to your specific needs, budget and brand preference.
What to Consider Before Choosing Your Battery Backup Sump Pump
Now it is your turn to take the above features comparisons and apply them to your specific needs. Consider the following questions to help you pinpoint which features matter most for your situation:
1. What is the size of your electric sump pump and basin?
- The size of your primary sump pump and the basin it operates in will determine the size and power requirements of the backup system. Be sure to match the backup pump capacity to your current system capacity (GPH at a 10 foot height assuming that it he vertical height of your discharge pipe system.) for seamless operation.
- Measure the dimensions of your sump pit. The diameter will determine if you need a battery backup sump pump that sits on the basin bottom or one that must be installed above the primary pump in line with the discharge pipe. The depth of the pit will determine the pumping power your basin can handle.
2. How often does your area experience power outages or flooding?
- If you live in an area prone to frequent storms, outages, or heavy rains, you will want a backup system that can handle prolonged operation. Consider how long you might need the backup pump to run on battery power alone. The best systems allow hooking two batteries in parallel to double the run time.
3. What is your budget?
- Battery backup sump pumps come in a wide range of prices, from budget-friendly models to high-end, heavy-duty systems. Knowing your budget will help you narrow down the options. Keep in mind that a more expensive system offer better performance and move features potentially saving you from future headaches.
4. What is the pump flow rate and capacity?
- The flow rate (gallons per minute, or GPM) and capacity (the amount of water it can move at once) are critical to making sure your sump pump can handle your home ground water drainage needs.
- Choosing a backup pump with a flow rate that matches or exceeds that of your primary pump ensures it is effective during heavy rain.
5. Do you need a pump with Wi-Fi Connectivity?
- Some battery backup sump pumps come with or offer Wi-Fi connectivity modules that alert you remotely when the battery backup system is running or has issues that need attention. This can be extremely helpful, so you are not left in the dark when an issue arises.
6. How easy is the system to install and maintain?
- White some systems are easy to install, others may require more effort. Consider whether you want a plug-and-play system or if you are comfortable with a more complex installation. What do reviews say about connecting the Wi-Fi feature?
7. Is the system reliable and durable?
- You want to ensure your backup sump pump is built to last, especially since it could be running in extreme conditions. Look for reviews and feedback from other homeowners to gauge reliability and durability. Look for models made from high-quality materials that can withstand heavy use.
8. Does the system have good customer support and warranty options?
- Excellent customer support and a strong warranty are important in case anything goes wrong. Check if the manufacturer offers a warranty on the pump and battery, and whether they provide responsive support in case of a failure..
Conclusion: Based On Your Needs, Which Battery Backup Sump Pump Is Right For You?
Now that you have gone through the questions, you should have a much clearer idea of which battery backup sump pump suits your needs. One of the main factors you considered is the pump flow rate and capacity. In case you need more clarification, here is a breakdown of the Top 9 battery backup pumps by pump performance.
The easiest way to review pump flow rate, pump performance, is to break the pumps into three performance tiers: High Performance, Average Performance, and Low Performance..
If you are looking for a top-of-the-line backup pump with strong pumping power and additional features like Wi-Fi connectivity, here are the best options:
1. Zoeller 508-0014
-Performance: This pump stands out with its high motor power, delivering exceptional pumping capacity: 34 GPM at 10 vertical feet. It is a top choice for those who need serious water removal.
-Key Features: Wi-Fi module included, hand-built and tested in the USA.
-Pit Size Requirement: Requires at least an 18-inch diameter and 24-inch deep pit due to its powerful motor.
2. Zoeller Aquanot Spin 508-0005
-Performance: This pump offers the same powerful performance (high motor power, delivering exceptional pumping capacity 34 GPM at 10 vertical feet) as the 508-0014, but without the Wi-Fi feature.
-Key Features: Excellent build quality and reliability, no Wi-Fi connectivity.
-Pit Size Requirement: Requires the same pit szie as the Zoeller 508-90014: at least an 18-inch diameter and 24-inch depth.
3. Basement Watchdog BWD12-120 (Big Dog)
-Performance: This pump delivers 37 GPM and 2,250 GPH at 10 feet vertical height, making it another excellent high-performance option.
-Wi-Fi Connectivity: Module BW-Wi-Fi2 must be purchased separately and added to BWD12-120 to connect to Wi-Fi..
-Pit Size Requirement: The pump can be installed above the primary pump in line with the primary pump PVC discharge piping to accommodate a narrower pit.
Recommendation
- If you need the best performance without Wi-Fi, the Zoeller 508-0005 offers a stronger motor and better quality for the same price as the Basement Watchdog Big Dog BWD12-120 (BW-Wi-Fi module not included)..
- If Wi-Fi connectivity is needed, the Basement Watchdog BWD12-120 with BW-Wi-Fi is more budget friendly by $125.00.
Average Volume Performance Battery Backup Pumps
These pumps offer solid performance, like an average 1/3 HP primary pump, making them ideal for average-sized homes or where high pumping power is not a necessity:
1 Wayne ESP25n
-Performance: 25 GPM and 1,500 GPH at 10 feet vertical height. A good fit for most moderate water flow situations.
-Wi-Fi Connectivity: Does not support Wi-Fi.
2. Basement Watchdog BWSP (Special)
-Performance: 30 GPM and 1,800 GPH at 10 feet vertical height. It offers a bit more power than the Wayne ESP25n.
-Wi-Fi Connectivity: Can be Wi-Fi enabled with the addition of the BW-Wi-Fi accessory, making it the most budget-friendly Wi-Fi option.
3. Liberty Pumps StormCell 442-10A & 442-25A
-Performance: 30.5 GPM and 1,830 GPH at 10 feet vertical height.
-Wi-Fi Connectivity: These models support Wi-Fi when the NightEye Wi-Fi accessory is purchased separately.
Recommendation
- If you need Wi-Fi but are on a budget, the Basement Watchdog BWSP is the most affordable option.
- If you need high-end Wi-Fi connectivity and Alexa compatibility, the Liberty Pumps StormCell models offer the best option.
Low Volume Performance Backup Pumps
These pumps are more basic and best for smaller homes or situations where you do not need a high pumping volume. They are comparable to a 1/4 HP primary sump pump.
1. Superior Pump 929100 & 92910
-Performance: 18 GPM and 1,080 GPH at 10 feet vertical height..
-Key Feature: Superior Pump 929100 is a tether float switch model. Wi-Fi.
-Wi-Fi Connectivity: Does not support Wi-Fi.
2. Basement Watchdog BWE (Emergency)
-Performance: 16 GPM and 1,000 GPH at 10 feet vertical height. A good option for those who need a simple, affordable backup pump.
-Wi-Fi Connectivity: Does not support Wi-Fi.
3. Zoeller Aquanot Key 507-0005
-Performance: 15 GPM and 900 GPH at 10 feet vertical height. A no-frills backup pump that gets the job done in low to moderate conditions.
-Key Feature: Well-built motor.
-Wi-Fi Connectivity: Does not support Wi-Fi.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right backup sump pump depends on your specific needs.
- If you want top performance and smart home integration Zoeller 508-0014 is the way to go.
- If you are looking for good value, the Superior Pump 92900 offers the best value with its tether float switch and the Superior Pump 92910 offers the best value with its vertical float switch for automatic operation.
Recommendation
- If you do not need Wi-Fi and are looking for basic, reliable performance equal to a 1/4 HP primary pump Zoeller 508-0014 is the way to go. For a balance between price and features, the Basement Watchdog BWD12-120 (Big Dog)is a strong contender. For those on a budget or with lower pumping requirements, the Superior Pump or Basement Watchdog BWE are both good, cost-effective choices.
- In the end, consider what matters most to you: pumping performance, Wi-Fi connectivity, or price. We hope this guide helps you find the best backup pump for your home!
Manufactures make it easy for home owners by providing a Users Installation Guide; however watching someone actually install a battery backup sump pump gives additional confidence, The following videos are created and provided by Zoeller and Basement Watchdog.
Zoeller Aquanot Fit 508 Installation Tips And Tricks Video by Zoeller Pump Company.
Basement Watchdog Backup Sump Pump Installation Video
Quick Shop Top 9 Battery Backup Sump Pumps
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Your purchase price is the same as if you shop directly on Amazon.
The price at time of publish is included to give you an idea of what the price is; however it is subject to change.
Select the Battery Backup Sump Pump Brand of interest or scroll to see all brands.
THE HELPFUL PUMP PLACE where you can become an educated shopper. Review - Compare - Shop And Find The Best Pumps Selection For Your Water Pumping Needs.
