Sump Pump Check Valve Review

One-way Valve Prevents Water From Returning To Basin And Protects Sump Pump Motor

Pumps Selection Review Shows Check Valves Prevent Water Hammer

Shop For The Best
Best Pump Selection for your Water Pumping Needs
×SUMP PUMP CHECK VALVE =>SIMILARITIES=>DIFFERENCES=>INSTALLATION=>PLACEMENTQUICK SHOP=>FAILURE=>NOISE=>REVIEWSHELPFUL RESOURCE LINKS
 
 
    SUMP PUMP CHECK VALVE TOPIC (PAGE) CONTENT
   (Click A Menu Topic To See More Specific Information; Scroll down the page to see all Menu Topic Information.)
 

Review Of Sump Pump Check Valve By Comparison Reveals Similaries And Differences

Do you really need a check valve? Or can you remove the check valve from your discharge piping system because it makes so much noise?

 

Your Sump Pump System Needs A Check Valve

Installed Sump Pump Check-Valve at Pumps Selection

Without a check valve your pump keeps repumping water already removed from the basin. When the motor shuts off, the water remaininig in the discharge pipe flows backward and down the vertical section of the discharge piping system. Without a check valve the water runs back through the pump into the pit. When the switch is activated that same water will be pumping out of the basin again. When a check valve is installed, the water flowing backwards after the motor shut off hits the check valve gate which prevents the water from flowing back through the pump. The water that has flown backwards will sit above the valve gate until the pump runs again. If the check vavle gate was not in place, the motor would keep pumping the same water over and over again and will burn out. When the water flows backward it has a lot of force. It is this force that causes a slamming thud sound. This slamming hammer sound can be reduced greatly by installing a quiet check valve.

The following information will help you understand the purpose of a check valve, the different styles, how the styles compare, how to install them and how the differences in construction make some of them quieter.

 

 
 
 

Sump Pump Check Valve Similarities

Sump Pump Check Valve Styles at Pumps Selection

One-way valves. All check values for sump pumps are one-way valves. The purpose of a check valve is to allow the water to flow through it up the discharge pipe, but prevent the water from flowing backwards below the check valve so the same water does not return to the sump pit over and over burning out the pump motor.

A gate or flapper. All check valves must have a gate or flapper that closes when the pump stops running. The gate or flapper allows water to pass up through it when the pump motor with the force created by the impeller pushes the water upwards through the discharge pipe.

The gate (flapper) closes when the water comes flowing backwards down the discharge pipe after the pump shuts off because there is no more pressure to push the water up. Gravity takes over and allows the water to run back down the pipe upon pump shut off.

Two end connectors. All check values have connectors at each end of the valve so they can be attached inline with the existing discharge piping.

Check valves are meant to be installed inline with the discharge piping system.

Go back to Sump Pump Check Valve topics

PAGE MENU
 
 
 

Sump Pump Check Valve Differences

The Connection Of The Check Valve To The Discharge Pipe Varies By Manufacturer

True Union Connector for Check-Valve

 

True union couplings is a connection in which the check valve can be screwed and unscrewed easily for valve replacement. The union coupling has two ends. One end is screwed into the check valve body (this makes it easy to screw the check valve body out easily). The other end of the union coupling fits inside the PVC discharge piping system. The end that fits into the PVC pipe must be primed and cemented (the purple and clear liquids). An O-ring is seated inside the union that screws. This provides a very tight seal preventing leakage. The check-valve pictured on the right is known as a union x union coonection. The check-valve body is that of a quiet check valve.

Hose Clamp x Hose Clamp Connector for Check-Valve

Hose Clamp x Hose Clamp connector is a connection in which a rubber connector  comes already slipped over both ends of the check-valve body.The other end of the rubber connector is sliped over the end of the discharge piping system. Clamps are screwed over the slip connections and tightened with a flat head screw driver to prevent water from dripping out.  The slip x slip connector makes it easy to remove the check valve body for replacement. Over time it is possible the clamps will loosen and water will seep out. In that case, just take the screw driver and tighten the clamsps again. This type of connection requires no glusing.

 

Slip x Slip Connector type  for Check-Valve

Slip x Slip Connector type is one where both ends of the check valve slip over discharge piping system. The end that fits over the PVC pipe must be primed and cemented (the purple and clear liquids) to the discharge pipe. This eliminates the possibillity of water seeping through the connection; however the discharge pipe system must be cut when the check valve must be replaced. To install a new check valve may require an additional disharge piping piece and a connector or union to replace the length of PVC that was cut out.

FIPT x FIPT Connector type  for Check-Valve

FIPT x FIPT Connector type is not too commen. Both end of the check valve are threaded on the inside so can be connected to a threaded male PVC of the same size.

Go back to Sump Pump Check Valve topics
PAGE MENU
 
 
 

The Material Used For The Check Valve Chamber Wall Varies By Manufacturer

Cast Iron Cast iron is extremely durable. It will withstand the water pressure and not be affected by the chemicals found in the water. This type of check valve uses a flapper to stop the water when it flows backwards down the discharge pipe to the check valve.

Strong Plastic (PVC)Strong plastic can also withstand high water pressure and will not be affected by the chemicals found in the ground water. Both flappers and gates are used for this type of material.

Go back to Sump Pump Check Valve topics
PAGE MENU
 
 
 

The Way To Identify Check Valve Failure Varies.

Usage of clear plastic The usage of clear plastic for the walls of the check valve chamber make it easy for the homeowner to view its operation. A check-valve failure can be seen by watching how the gate opens and closes.

Usage of non opaque solid plastic or iron The usage of non opaque plastic and iron makes it impossible for the homeowner to view the chamber during operation. The homeowner will know the check-valve flapper or gate has failed when water runs down the discharge pipe after the pump has shut off and water is flowing backwards toward the check valve. The check valve will not hold the water above its gate or flapper.

Go back to Sump Pump Check Valve topics
Go to Check Valves Quick Shop and check models and prices.
PAGE MENU
 
 
 

The Design Of The Inner Chamber And Type Of Gate Used Varies By Manufacturer

A hydodynamic design inside the check valve chamber makes a difference. Such a design influences the degree of pressure loss and air entry. Likewise a tightly fit seal controls the amount of water and air pressure change. A design which controls the pressure change and allows the gate to close quickly reduces the likelihood of water hammer.

Connector type  for Check-Valve

A flapper swing does not control the impact of the water pressure. It merely responds to the increase and decrese of pressure. Pit water gains pressure as the level of water rises in the pit, as the motor is running and as the pump impeller increases water flow velocity. The flapper opens when the pressure increases. When the pump motor shuts off, the water pressure and velocity greatly decrease and the force of gravity causes it to flow backwards and down the discharge pipe. The backward flow of the water pushes against the flapper and causes it to close.

Connector type  for Check-Valve

A spring loaded gate uses a heavy-duty tension spring to take control over the effects of the pressure and velocity of water flow and keeps the pressure constant as much as possible. At a predemined degree of pressure, the tension spring allows the gate to open upward. Likewise the spring will close the gate when the water begins flowing backwards. The tension spring minimizes the change of the increasing and decreasing level of pressure to the extent that water hammer is not heard.

Go back to Sump Pump Check Valve topics
Go to Check Valves Quick Shop and check models and prices.
PAGE MENU
 
 
 

The Closing Noise Of The Gate Or Flapper Varies

A flapper swing makes the most noise because the water pressure causes the flappers movement. The lose of water pressure and velocity when the pump shuts off causes the water to flow backward. As the water flows backward it hits the flapper, causes it to shut and causes a slamming or thudding sound.

A spring loaded gate is the quietest because the spring controls the movement of the gate. The tension of the spring keeps the pressure as constant as possible and responds in a controlled manner when the water pressure decreases as a result of the pump motor shutting off. The pressure change when the water flows back to the closed gate is less which causes very little sound.

Go back to Sump Pump Check Valve topics
PAGE MENU
 
 
 

How To Do Sump Pump Check Valve Installation

Check Valve Installation Is Easy

Steps For Installing Check Valve.

Step 1. Remove water and debris and peffles from pit

STEP 1

Remove as much water from the sump pit as possible. Also remove small pebbles, sludge and debris as well. Small pebbles can get caught in the check valve chamber and cause it to fail.

Step 2. Check the new check valve length with the old one.

STEP 2

Check the new check valve length with the old one. Obviously replacing the same check valve with a new one is easiest because the lengths will be the same.

Step 3. Disconnect the lower end of the old check valve from the discharge pipe.

STEP 3

Unplug the pump cord. Disconnect the lower end of the old check valve from the discharge pipe.

 

Step 4. Release the water from the old check valve.

STEP 4

Release the water from the old check valve. Drain the water into a 5 gallon pail.

Step 5. Remove the top part of the check valve from the discharge pipe.

STEP 5

Remove the top part of the check valve from the discharge pipe.

Step 6. Measure how long the bottom discharge pipe needs to be

STEP 6

Check if the bottom discharge pipe attached to the pump is too short or too long. If it is short, add another piece of PVC. If it is too long, measure where the pipe needs to be cut so the new check valve will fit in place.

 

Step 7. Cut off excess length

STEP 7

Cut off the excess length of the bottom pipe where you measured with a hack saw.

Step 8. Connect the union of the new check valve to the bottom pipe.

STEP 8

If a slip x slip connections is used, steps 8 through 15 are not necessry. With a union connection, connect the nut of the union of the new check valve to the bottom pipe. Prime and glue it in place.

Step 9. Do a dry run of fitting top part together with check valve portion

STEP 9

Do a dry run to see if remaining check valve piece fit between top and bottom of discharge pipe system.

 

Step 10. Screw the check valve portion. Check if it fits.

STEP 10

Do a dry run to see if the check valve chamber fits in between the top and bottom of discharge pipe system.

Step 11. Make sure arrow of check valve point up

STEP 11

Make sure the check valve chamber is placed in the right direction. Find the arrow on the check valve chamber. Make sure it points 'up' The gate should be placed so the water hits it from the top.

Step 12. Prime the piping

STEP 12

After doing a dry fitting, prime the piping and fittings.

 

Step 13. Glue ends and fittings

STEP 13

Glue fittings one by one.

Step 14. Hold fittings

STEP 14

Hold fittings until they set.

Step 15. Screw the check valve in place

STEP 15

Screw the check valve in place.

 

Step 16. Use a wrench to tighten a little more

STEP 16

After hand tightening, use a wrench to tighten a little bit more so there a no leaks.

Step 17. Plug the pump in.

STEP 17

Plug the pump into an electrical outlet. Look for leaks. Check for unusual running water sounds or shootiing water when the pump shuts off. If none, your project is done.

Go back to Sump Pump Check Valve topics
Go to Check Valves Quick Shop and check models and prices.
PAGE MENU
 
 
 

Sump Pump Check Valve Placement

Manufacturers recommend sump pump check valve placement be three feet (36 inches)above the sump pump. Many sump pump pits are around 24 inches (two feet) deep therefore the check valve would be placed 12 inches (one foot) above the sump pit cover or twelve inches above the basement floor.

Always check the Manufactures User Installation Guide for additional information regarding installation of the check valve height for your primary (main)sump pump.

Go back to Sump Pump Check Valve topics
PAGE MENU
 
 
 

Sump Pump Check Valve Failure Identified

A flapper swing designed check valve failure will show water dripping from the check valve downward into the pit when water is pumping through the discharge pipe. Here is a good example of what it looks like.

 
 

By shaking a check valve you will be able to hear the failed flapper bouncing around. Here is a good example of what it sounds like.

 
 
Go back to Sump Pump Check Valve topics
Go to Check Valves Quick Shop and check models and prices.
PAGE MENU
 
 

Remedy For Sump Pump Check Valve Noise

Spring Loaded Check Valve Is Quietest

The spring loaded check valve closes much quicker than the swing (flapper) style. The faster the valve closes the less noise because the velocity or pressure of the water coming back down the discharge pipe system toward the pit is less. The water pressure change and flow velocity affect the noise level.

Go back to Sump Pump Check Valve topics

 
 
 

Consumer Reviews For Swing Flapper Style Check Valve

The Zoeller 30-0181 is a Number One Best Seller. Overall it has a rating of 4.7 out of 5. Of the 243 consumers reviews, 183 gave it a 5 star; 43 gave it a 4 star.

 

A summary of the reviews indicates the Flapper Swing style check valve works great, it is easy to install; it is well worth the cost.

One of the consumers, Victor Agresti, describes the mechanical workings of the check valve as the following. When the sump pump comes on, the valve flap swings completely out of the way, to allow maximum flow. When the pump stops, the flap closes to stop water from going toward the pump. He has also found another unique purpose for the check valve. A check valve prevents mice, insects, etc. that crawled in through your exit pipe, from making it all the way to your sump pump. When the water comes on, critters should be washed away.

 
Good Flow Check Valve August 8, 2014.
John Hamperson, Maryland

The Zoeller 30-0181 has a full flow design. The flapper opens completely, unlike many cheaper valves. The connector for this is versatile. It is a 1 1/4 inch design with universal rubber couplings that connect it to either 1 1/4 inch or 1 1/2 inch PVC pipe. When it is installed you need to turn the rubber couplings one way or the other to accommodate the correct PVC pipe diameter for your application. The check valve does klunk with a loud snap but this doesn not bother me. The quality is good and it is a good choice for me.

 
Few tools needed to install July 8, 2014.
Tom Carlson, Minneapolis, MN

The Zoeller 30-0181 check valve is easy to install. You only need a standard screwdriver for installation if you are replacing an old valve and maybe a hacksaw if you need to cut away some of the pvc pipe to allow for the proper fit.

There were arrows printed right on the valve to help me fit in the proper direction so it opens and closes in the correct direction. I am no plumber, but installing this was easy. I was surprised how easy it was.

The price on these is great, they are built very well. This was a great investment.

 
Works Fine. After 5 years July 8, 2014.
Adam Pearson, Duluth, MN

I bought the Zoeller check valve and have it installed for five plus years. It is working great so I am buying another one. One thing I have noticed is that with a rigid PVC piping the pump and discharge line move around a bit when the pump stops. My pump has plenty of room so the float will not get caught on the pit wall.

Every winter I have to remove the check valve because the discharge line freezes solid in the coldest Minnesota weather with our old, drafty house and its cold basement. Removing the check valve allows the discharge line to drain completely after each cycle.

In the spring I reattach the check valve and evertying is fine. The clamps and adapters included with this pump make the attachment and reattachment job a breeze. The connectors show no signs of wear from the regular changes. I have had it installed for 5 years now and it is still working fine.

 
Excellent value March 8, 2014.
Adam Pearson, Duluth, MN

This seems to be a much better engineered product than what I found on the shelf at my local hardware store. The cost is the same so I am glad I bought the Zoeller Check valve.

The check valve does exactly what it is supposed to do - keep water in the discharge hose from backing up into the sump pit. I am happy I bought it.

Go back to Sump Pump Check Valve topics
Go to Check Valves Quick Shop and check models and prices.
 
 
 

Consumer Reviews Spring Loaded Gste (Quiet) Check Valve

The Quiet Check Valve

The Campbell Mfg. Spring Quiet Check Valve B-0823-15C is a Number One Best Seller. Overall it has a rating of 4.9 out of 5. Of the 304 consumers reviews, 285 gave it a 5 star; 10 gave it a 4 star.

A summary of the reviews indicates that consumers like the fact they can see the check valve work when the pump runs; the quiet check valve is easy to install; it works great; it is so quiet compared to the other kind; it is well worth the money.

One of the consumers,Roy, indicates he has tried check valve types over the years to eliminat the dreaded thud and none of them have worked very well. They were all designed the same way and obviously all had the same result....THUD. This check valve has a much better design. A design that I think should almost be mandatory!! It took just 15 minutes to install. You will need the plumbing cleaner & cement for the connectors.

A Perfect Check Valve. September 8, 2014.
Joe Swanson, Chicago, IL

I purchased the Campbell B-0823-15C Quiet check valve. I installed it for my primary pump. I liked it so well I bought one for my backup pump as well. It is really a great design bacause by having the threaded couplers it is easy to disconnect the pump or the check valve. What a big improvement over what I have before. I also like the fact that the chamber is transparent. I can see if there is any debris or sediment that needs to be cleaned out. My pumps and check valves are both quiet now. I check to see if the valve opens and closes because I cannot hear it running.

Brilliant and Quiet Check Valve.September 2, 2014.
Mark Johnson, Milwaukee, WI

We had a clanging noise coming down our vertical pipe that is attached to the pump. I was not sure if we have a bad discharge pipe or what. Now that I have installed the Campbell Mfg 1.5 inch Quiet Check Valve B-0823-15C I know the sound came from our old check valve. The loud noise could be heard throughout the house. Now with this quiet check valve, I almost cannot even tell if the pump is running when I am next to it. What a brilliant design. I would recommend this to anyone.

This is quality September 2, 2014.
Mark Thompson, Milwaukee

The Campbell Quiet check valve really impressed me. When I picked the packaging box up the B-0823-15C was heavy. When I opened the box and saw it, I knew I had a quality product. This is extremely heavy duty. The clear plastic is quality. This product allows you to solvent weld (PVC glue) the check valve in place. When the unit needs to be replaced it will only take seconds to unscrew the o-ring unions on each side of the check valve and drop a new one in. This check valve is far superior to the rubber fernco type fitting on each end. I need to order another one because it is good to have such a good quality product on hand.

The flap gate is strong. July 2, 2014.
Doctor Brown, Barrington, IL

I am impressed. The Campbell Silent check valve is really quiet. I am amazed at how it works. The pressure in the chamber and the design of the spring gate prevent the flap from slamming shut. Before I bought this I had a cheap one that had flaps that could not hold the pressure weight of the water above it. The old valve flaps were flimsy and they broke downward through the hole, thus causing back flow when the back-up sump was operating.

The quiet check valve uses a very hard, sturdy plastic gate flap that does not look like water pressure can break it through the lower opening. I really like the look-through, transparent chamber because you can see whether the gate is functioning when you test it. I have been used to the slip x slip connectors so I replaced the plastic screw couplers with rubber connectors for about $2.50 each to connect the top end of the tube. So far the quiet valve has been through 5 years of heavy rainstorms and is working fine. So far so good.

Go back to Sump Pump Check Valve topics
Go to Check Valves Quick Shop and check models and prices.
 
 

QUICK SHOP TRADITIONAL (SWING GATE - FLAPPER) AND
QUIET CHECK VALVES (SPRING LOADED GATE) FOR SUMP PUMPS

 
 
 

BEST RATED BEST SELLERS TOP EIGHT
QUIET CHECK VALVES FOR SUMP PUMPS

 

 

 

BEST RATED BEST SELLERS TOP THREE
TRADITIONAL SWING CHECK VALVES FOR SUMP PUMPS

 

 

QUICK SHOP TRADITIONAL SWING FLAPPER CHECK VALVES FOR SUMP PUMPS

 

 

 

SHOP QUIET & TRADITIONAL BY DIAMETER SIZE

 
 
 
OUR MISSION

THE HELPFUL PUMP PLACE where you can become an educated shopper. Review - Compare - Shop for the Best Water Pump For Your Water Pumping Needs.

SHARE US

 

 
 
© 2009, All Rights Reserved
Find the best pump selection for your pumping needs today at lowest prices.
pumpsselection.com