A Comparison Of Zoeller Sump Pump vs Everbilt Pump Reveals 3 Big Differences. Zoeller Is The Gold Standard For Where Made, Testing and Replacement Parts. The Everbilt Cast Iron One-Third HP Sump Pump Has A Higher Pump Performance Than The Zoeller M50 Series Pumps; though The One-Half Horse Power Everbilt Pump Does Not Have A Higher Pump Performance. See If The Highlighted Facts Make A Difference To You. Be An Informed Shopper.
Zoeller Sump Pump vs Everbilt Sump Pump Table Of Contents
Zoeller's Professional, Premium and Flow Mate submersible sump pump models are made in the USA. Zoeller has been in the pump manufacturing business since 1939 and is headquartered in Louisville, Kentucky.
Zoeller is a family owned business and a full pledged USA pump manufacturing company doing the design engineering, manufacturing, assembling, testing, packing, shipping, marketing, training and support. They make and manufacturer their pumps (the Professional, Premium and Flow Mate Models) and are proud to be known as a Made In The USA company.
Everbilt is located in Ashland Ohio. They are a trademark of Home Depot as of October 2014 so provide pumps according to a Home Depot contract.
Everbilt, part of the Ashland Water Group, is responsible for the engineering design and marketing of the Everbilt and Eco-Flo pumps. China actually manufactures and packages the Everbuilt and Eco-Flo pumps.
Zoeller sump pump is factory tested. In fact two tests are performed on each sump pump: a leak test and a performance test. Since each pump is tested before leaving the factory, the installer can be assured that the pump will work when installed.
Only a representative sample of Everbilt pumps are randomly tested to ensure the model's design is capable of meeting the published pump performance numbers. The warranty is used to cover sump pumps that may fail when initially installed or soon thereafter. Both brands have a three year warranty.
The float switch is generally the first thing to fail on a sump pump because it is a mechanical part. Because Zoeller pumps are built to last several decades, switches and other parts are easy to purchase online from multiple websites and even a do-it-yourself home owner can install a replacement switch. This option replaces the Switch Cap. This is a quick way to replace the switch because a new switch comes preinstalled in the new cap.
Everbilt does provide replacement switches for its cast iron sump pumps; they can be purchased from Home Depot.
Both Zoeller and Everbilt use a snap action float switch on their cast iron models. This is the best option for an integrated vertical float switch. Here's why.
Ground water contains mineral contaminates. Over time these contaminates build on the float to switch connector and weaken the connection. Without a solid connection, the switch will fail to operate properly. Either it will fail to connect and stay in the OFF position or it will connect and fail to disconnect when the water recedes in the basin. Such switch action causes sump pump failure.
The snap action vertical float switch relies on friction force caused when the water raises the float in the pit to the switch ON point which connects the positive and negative electric circuits in the switch case and the electric current flows to the pump.
The switch parts are sealed from mineral contamination and water by a rubber gasket sitting between the switch case and the pump housing with the motor.
Installing a Zoeller pump does have an advantage however because its replacement switch parts are very easy to purchase online and install for a do-it-yourself home owner.
Regardless of the vertical height the water is pumped, the Everbilt one-third HP cast iron sump pump has a better pump performance; the Everbilt HDS30 can pump 600 gallons more per hour than the Zoeller 1/3 HP pump.
The Zoeller M53, M55, M57, M59 and M63 1/3 HP cast iron sump pumps 2680 GPH (44 GPM) at 0 feet; 2680 GPH at 5 feet (44 GPM); and 2,040 GPH (34 GPM) at a 10 foot vertical height.
The Everbilt HDS30 pumps 3510 GPH (58 GPM) at 0 feet and 2540 GPH (42 GPM) at 10 foot vertical height.
The upgraded Zoeller M95 can pump 180 gallons more per hour at a 10 foot vertical height than the Zoeller M98 and the Everbilt HDS50.
The Zoeller upgraded M95 pumps 4800 GPH (80 GPM) at a 0 vertical height and 3960 GPH (66 GPM) at a 10 foot vertical height. The Zoeller M98 sump pump with cast iron housing pumps 4320 GPH (72 GPM) at 0 feet and 3,660 GPH (61) at a 10 foot vertical height.
The Everbilt HDS50 1/2 HP cast iron sump pumps 5100 GPH (85 GPM) at 0 feet and 3780 GPH (63 GPM) at 10 foot vertical height.
Zoeller does not make a three-fourths HP sump pump.
The Everbilt HDS75 3/4 HP cast iron sump pumps 6000 GPH (100 GPM) at 0 feet and 4800 GPH (80 GPM) at 10 foot vertical height.
Both brands add a powder coated epoxy finish to the cast iron to retard rust. The Zoeller sump pump housing is known to last as long as 40 years without rusting through.
The fasteners are made of stainless steel. Stainless steel will not rust.
Zoeller's sump pump motors are best.
We recommend Zoeller sump pump motors even though Everbilt motors pump more water per hour.
Zoeller makes their own motors in the USA. Everbilt motors are made in China.
Zoeller pumps use two layers of cast iron to dissipate motor heat: the motor housing is cast iron and the pump body housing is cast iron. An air vacuum is created between the two layers to also effectively pass the heat from the pump. Good heat dissipation extends the life of a motor.
Zoeller motors are designed to keep 20% of their available capability in reserve to handle an additional demand.
For Everbilt pumps the motor housing is also the pump body housing. There are not two layers of cast iron housing to dissipate heat.
The Everbilt cast iron sump pumps are more energy efficient than the Zoeller models.
The Everbilt HDS30, a one-third HP, is most energy efficient using 6.5 Amps. The Everbilt cast iron pump HDS50 uses 8.5 Amps while the Zoeller M50 Series and the M63 use 9.7 Amps. The M98 uses 9.7 Amps and the M95 uses 10.5 Amps.
The electricity cost of using a ¼ HP and a 1/3 HP sump pump is around $10 - $20 a month when used heavily during rainy months. The electricity cost for using a ½ HP and ¾ HP pump is around $30 - $40 a month during heavy usage.
When converting Amps to wattage, 6.5 Amps is 780 watts; 8.5 Amps is 1020 watts and 9.7 Amps is 1164 watts.
Yes, these Zoeller and Everbilt sump pumps can be installed outdoors and submerged in water. The electrical parts that could be affected by water are sealed so no water can affect them. It is common for sump pump basins to be installed outdoors next to the house. It does not matter how much the sump pump is submerged in a water catch basin; they are made to be submersed in water.
Yes, both the Zoeller and Everbilt use a vortex impeller which means they are capable of handling solids one-half inch or so. Using a vortex impeller is helpful for basins that contain small pea gravel or other small debris. These sump do not use a bottom screen which can become clogged and result is pump failure if not cleaned.
We have tried Big Box Store brands but they do not last long for us. The switch fails too quickly. We are grateful our plumber friend recommended Zoeller to us many years ago. Zoeller offers so many advantages as we have already mentioned above and throughout our website.
We are very happy with our Zoeller sump pumps and sewage pump. Our M53 is 17 years old and still running. We have replaced the switch and gasket once. It was easy to replace. Our M267 is 10 years old and is still running. We have had no issues with it. Our M98 is 9 years old and still running without issues.
The installation of a Zoeller and Everbilt are the same though the Everbilt pumps are slightly over one-half inch wider in diameter.
Step 1 - Unplug the old pump from the electrical wall socket. A sump pump should not use an extension cord and needs its own wall socket.
Step 2 - Detach the check valve from the discharge piping. Detach the old sump pump from the discharge pipe. Remove the pump from the basin and empty trapped water.
Step 3 - Remove the new pump from its packaging. Add the connector to the pump discharge port along with a length of discharge piping. In most cases the old discharge pipe can be used. Check its length. It may need to be shortened or another piece added.
Step 4 - Install a new quiet check valve. A new check valve is recommended whenever a new pump is installed. The check valve prevents water from recycling through the pump and back into the basin when the motor stops. It extends the life of a pump motor.
Step 5 - Place the pump in the pit to check discharge pipe length and adjust accordingly.
Step 6 - Make sure the pump is sitting solid in the basin. Attach the pump discharge pipe to the check valve. Plug the pump power cord into the wall socket.
Step 7 - Pour enough water into the basin to cause the pump to run. Check for leaks. If there are no leaks and the pump runs quietly and removes the water from the pit, you are done.
Congratulations on a successful installation of your new sump pump.
Watching the replacement of an old sump pump with a new one gives a do-it-yourself homeowner confidence that they too can install their own sump pump. Installing a sump pump one's self certainly saves time and money.
Everbilt sump pumps are very easy to buy if you live near a Home Depot Hardware store. Everbilt is Home Depot's contracted product. Everbilt can be easily purchased online if a Home Depot is not located in your neighborhood. Amazon offers good pricing and shipping.
Zoeller sump pumps may be included online as merchandize by brick and mortar brand stores, but rarely are these pump in stock in the store. Thus ordering online is the quickest way from online sites like Amazon where you will find the best price.
The cost for a new cast iron Zoeller or Everbilt sump pump is very similar: around $200. At the time of writing the difference between Zoeller and Everbilt was $5 and $10. So cost is not the big deciding factor for which pump brand to purchase.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Your purchase price is the same as if you shop directly on Amazon. The price at time of publish is included below to give you an idea of what the price is; however it is subject to change.
SHOP ZOELLER SUMP PUMPS AUTOMATIC
M53
M57
M95
SHOP ZOELLER SUMP PUMPS NON AUTOMATIC CHOOSE YOUR OWN FLOAT SWITCH
N53
N55
N57
N59
N98
SHOP ZOELLER SUMP PUMP REPLACEMENT SWITCH PARTS
004705
004705 Switch Assembly 50 No Gasket for Zoeller M53, M55, M57, and M59
004892
004892 Switch Assembly And Gasket For Zoeller M53, M55, M57, M59, M98
004740
004740 Replacement Switch For Zoeller M137 And M266 and M267 Sewage Pumps
004702
>Cap and Switch Assembly Part No. 004702 for Zoeller M53, M55, M57, M59, M98, M137
034046
034046 Replacement Gasket For Zoeller M53, M55, M57, M59, M98
SHOP EVERBILT SUMP PUMPS
HDS30
HDS50
HELPFUL RESOURCE LINKS TO COMPARE AND SHOP PUMPS
POPULAR BRANDS
BEST SELLERS
DETAILED PUMP REVIEWS
OTHER HELPFUL WEBSITES
OUR MISSION
SHARE US
